all critiques

Elephant and calf on the track

wildlife photo critique

Photo by Charles J. Sharp

EXIF
Camera
Canon Canon EOS 80D
Lens
EF100-400mm f/4.5-5.6L IS II USM
Focal length 107 mm
Aperture f / 4.5
Shutter 1/800 s
ISO ISO 200
Exp. comp. -0.33 EV
Shot at 17:36 · Mar 14, 2018
7.4
overall
7.2
composition
6.8
lighting
7.5
exposure
7.3
tones
7.6
technical
Overall
7.4 / 10

A warm, storytelling pairing — mother and calf walking a bush track — that carries genuine appeal through relationship rather than just a single animal. The adult's face and eye are well rendered, the calf feeding fresh interest to the right of the frame. What most holds the shot back is the light: high, fairly flat morning sun leaves the grey hides slightly muddy and the mother's front leg and trunk in shadow. The wide track composition works but leaves considerable empty foreground track that a slightly tighter frame would tighten. Solid, publishable, and a genuinely engaging moment.

Composition
7.2 / 10

The two-subject arrangement reads clearly, the mother anchoring the left-centre and the calf providing a satisfying secondary weight to the right, connected by the diagonal of the track. The green wall of bush frames the left effectively. However, the mother sits close to dead centre while the empty foreground track eats a large chunk of the lower frame without adding much. The calf is slightly clipped by breathing room on the right that feels tight against the abundant space elsewhere. Rebalancing would strengthen the pairing.

storytelling pair natural framing centred subject empty foreground
Lighting
6.8 / 10

The light is the weakest element. High morning sun from the front-left gives even but flat illumination across the grey hides, flattening the texture that makes elephant skin compelling. The mother's inner front leg and lower trunk fall into shadow, and the ears carry some hard edge contrast. There are no strong catchlights beyond a faint one in the eye. Lower, warmer, more raking golden-hour light would model the wrinkled skin far better and separate the animals from the busy green background.

flat frontal light shadowed leg even exposure light
Exposure
7.5 / 10

Exposure is well judged for the difficult tonal spread. The dark hides retain shadow detail without blocking up, and the bright green foliage and sky hold together without significant clipping. The -0.33 EV compensation was a sensible call to protect the highlights against the bright morning scene. The mother's shadowed leg is the darkest passage but still holds information. Midtones sit a touch low, contributing to the slightly heavy feel of the grey subjects, but nothing here is broken.

protected highlights shadow detail held low midtones
Tones
7.3 / 10

The colour palette is pleasant and natural — warm dirt track, saturated greens, and neutral-to-cool greys on the elephants. White balance reads accurate for open morning shade. The greys lean slightly muddy and cool, which drains some life from the subjects against the vivid vegetation. Contrast is moderate and safe. A modest warmth lift on the hides and a touch more separation between the elephants' greys and the background greens would give the frame more depth and stop the animals melting slightly into their surroundings.

natural palette accurate white balance muddy greys
Technical
7.6 / 10

The 100-400mm L at 107mm was a sensible reach for this distance, and the execution is sound. Focus lands on the mother's eye and facial detail, which is exactly where it needs to be for wildlife; the skin texture across the face and ear is crisp. 1/800s at f/4.5 comfortably froze the slow walking motion — no motion blur on either animal. ISO 200 keeps the file clean with no meaningful noise. The one compromise is depth of field: at f/4.5 the calf, being further back and to the side, sits marginally softer than the mother, and the mother's own body from shoulder to rear shows some falloff. Stopping down to f/7.1 or f/8 would have carried sharpness across both animals while still leaving the background soft, and the ISO 200 headroom left plenty of room to do so without pushing shutter or noise. A minor call in an otherwise well-handled capture.

sharp eye motion frozen clean ISO shallow dof for pair

What would elevate it

1 A narrower aperture around f/7.1–f/8 would carry sharpness across both the mother and the calf, using the available ISO headroom.
2 Lower, warmer golden-hour light would model the wrinkled hide and separate the greys from the green background.
3 A slightly tighter crop trimming the empty foreground track would tighten the relationship between the two animals.

Tags

elephant wildlife pair safari telephoto shallow depth of field morning light dirt track green background animal behaviour

Share this critique

Here's the card — post it anywhere.

wildlife photo critique card

Shot something like this?

Expert photo critique, on demand — scored across six categories, EXIF-aware. Start with 3 free critiques, no credit card.

critique my photo — free